Compare Processors

7 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Credit Card Processor

The lowest quoted rate doesn't always win. These seven questions help you compare processors on what you'll actually pay and live with.

By Card Connect CommerceOctober 1, 20263 min read
Two payment terminals beside a comparison checklist
Illustrative image; not a customer case study.

Comparing processors is harder than it should be. Everyone leads with a rate, and the rates are hard to compare because they mean different things on different plans.

These seven questions get you past the sales pitch. Ask every processor the same ones, write down the answers, and compare side by side.

1. What kind of pricing plan is this?

Flat rate, tiered, or interchange-plus? Each one works differently, and it changes what the quoted number covers. If you're not sure what these mean, read Why Your Quoted Rate Isn't What You Pay first.

2. Based on my actual statement, what would I have paid last month?

This is the most useful question on the list. Hand over a recent statement and ask for a total, in dollars, for that same month. It turns a confusing rate into a number you can compare to what you really paid.

3. What are all the fees, besides the rate?

Ask for a written list. Monthly fees, yearly fees, PCI fees, statement fees, gateway fees, chargeback fees, batch fees. If the list is long, ask what each one is for.

4. How long is the contract, and does it renew automatically?

Some contracts run three years and renew on their own unless you cancel within a short window. Know the term and the renewal rules before you sign.

5. What does it cost to leave?

Ask about the early termination fee in plain terms. Is it a flat amount? Is it based on fees you would have paid? Is there any way to leave without it? This is the question people most often skip and most often regret.

6. Will my equipment and software work?

Ask whether your current terminal, point-of-sale system, and online store will work. If you need new equipment, ask whether you can buy it outright instead of leasing, and what each option costs over time.

7. Who do I call when something breaks?

Card machines tend to stop working at the worst moment. Ask how support works. Is it a phone line with a person, or a ticket system? What hours? Will you have one main contact who knows your account?

A simple comparison sheet

QuestionProcessor AProcessor B
Pricing plan  
Total cost on last month's statement  
Monthly and yearly fees  
Contract length / auto-renew  
Cost to leave  
Equipment and software fit  
Support  
Fill this in for each processor you talk to.

Compare total dollars on your own statement, not quoted rates. Then compare the contract and support, because you'll live with those for years.

What a useful answer actually looks like

If they say…Ask for…
You'll save moneyA written dollar estimate on your actual statement, with the assumptions and exclusions.
There's no contractThe processing agreement, cancellation requirements, and any separate equipment or software terms.
Your terminal should workCompatibility confirmation for the exact model and your point-of-sale integration.
We have great supportSupport hours, after-hours contacts, and the escalation process for missing deposits.
The equipment is freeOwnership, return requirements, replacement costs, and any commitment attached to it.
Specific written answers are easier to compare than reassurance during a sales call.

Ask a deposit question, too

"If I close a batch on Friday evening, when should I expect the deposit? What are the cutoff times, weekend rules, and circumstances that could lead to a reserve or funding hold?" A low fee isn't much comfort if the funding arrangement doesn't suit your cash flow. Get the applicable terms, not an unconditional promise of next-day money.

Before you sign anything

  1. Send each provider the same statement and describe the same payment setup. Remove customer payment data and use the provider's agreed secure method.
  2. Request the full fee schedule, processing agreement, and any separate lease or software agreement—not just the proposal page.
  3. Check the first-year total and the ongoing total, including what happens when promotions expire.
  4. Resolve missing answers in writing. If an important promise isn't reflected in the documents, don't assume it will apply.

Already with a processor and not sure if it's worth the trouble? Negotiate or Switch? covers that decision.

Further reading

Read the the FTC's guidance on credit card processing deals for background on checking sales claims and equipment commitments. Then compare the specific written agreements in front of you.

Want Us to Check Your Processing Costs for You?

You have a business to run. Let us take a closer look at your credit card processing statement and help you understand whether there's room for improvement.

Get My Free Processing Audit

No obligation. Just a closer look at what you're paying.

Free Processing Audit